Correlative strength of objective physical assessment against. In, ecog introduced the ecog ps scale with only six points, ranging from fully active to dead. Jul 19, 20 with respect to a patients functional status, the eastern cooperative oncology group performance status ecog ps, also called the who performance status or scale, is an often used alternative to the kps. Prognostic value of performance status in metastatic renal. Eastern cooperative oncology group ecog performance status 18. Concordance of barthel index, ecogps, and palliative. Karnofsky and ecog performance status scoring in lung. Determines ability of patient to tolerate therapies in serious illness, specifically for. Performance status assessment by using ecog eastern. Ecog performance status these scales and criteria are used by doctors and researchers to assess how a patients disease is progressing, assess how the disease affects the daily living abilities of the patient, and determine appropriate treatment and prognosis. The eastern cooperative oncology group performance status ecog. The ecog performance status is a scale used to assess how. Restricted in physically strenuous activity but ambulatory and able to carry out work of a light or sedentary nature, e. Eastern cooperative oncology group ecog, zubrod, world health organization performance scale.
Grade explanation of activity 0 fully active, able to carry on all predisease performance without restriction 1 restricted in physically strenuous activity but ambulatory and able to carry out work of a light or sedentary nature, e. Correlation of performance status ps with outcome measures in cancer. Ps scale is commonly used by physicians and nurses in oncology, as it correlates with cancer morbidity, mortality, and complications from chemotherapy and can help direct clinical decisions and prognostication. To duplicate the scale, please cite the reference above and credit the eastern cooperative oncology group, robert comis m. One advantage of ecog over other status evaluations is its simplicity. Mar 28, 2019 however, most oncologists preferred the ecog performance scale. Pdf appraisal of the karnofsky performance status and. The kps is an 11 point rating scale which ranges from normal functioning 100 to dead 0 in ten point increments.
Karnofsky and ecog performance status scoring in lung cancer. Performance scale timeline 1948 world pre chemo 1960 karnofsky ecog 1988 fast 1996 2001 v2 pps. The most commonly used is typically referred to as the zubrod or ecog eastern cooperative oncology group scale. Ecog, pps, and kps were completed by physicians for each new patient attending the. Zero indicates death and 100, normal physical performance. It describes a patients level of functioning in terms of their ability to care for. This scale is a modification of the karnofsky section 4 functional status of patient eastern cooperative oncology group ecog performance status scale grade scale 1 fully active able to carry on all predisease activities without restriction. Grade 0 indicates that the patients is fully active and able. The ecog performance status was chosen due to its widely accepted use in oncology care, and it was the only functional status metric routinely utilized with our population. Ambulatory and capable of all selfcare but unable to carry out any work activities. Karnosky performance status scale kps eastern cooperative oncology group ecog ecog performance status grade ecog 0 fully active, able to carry on all predisease performance without restriction. Performance status in patients with cancer oncology jama. However, most oncologists preferred the ecog performance scale. Registry operations and data standards roads lists codes for these data items.
The karnofsky performance scale index allows patients to be classified as to their functional impairment. Comparing the ecog performance status to the karnofsky performance status the ecog performance status and the karnofsky performance status are two widely used methods to assess the functional status of a. Ecog performance status, palliative care specialist, nurse, medical oncologist, advanced cancer introduction the eastern cooperative oncology group performance status ecog ps is a universal marker that can be used to determine the feasibility of chemotherapy or clinical trial eligibility in the. Appraisal of the karnofsky performance status and proposal of. Le scale karnofsky e ecogwho per pazienti oncologici. Ecog performance status grade ecog 0 fully active, able to carry on all predisease performance without restriction 1 restricted in physically strenuous activity but ambulatory and able to carry out work of a. We also offer several novel findings regarding the reliability and prognostic power of patientreported performance status assessment. Ecog introduced a simpler ecog performance status scale, similar to the karnofsky ps kps scale, with only five points. Eastern cooperative oncology group ecog performance status.
The other scale sometimes used is the karnofsky scale. The eastern cooperative oncology groupworld health organization performance status ecog who ps is a prognostic factor. It cannot be altered or used in any way other than as intended and described here. The eastern cooperative oncology group ecog score published by oken et al. Kelly 1 andarminshahrokni 1,2 gastrointestinal oncology service, department of medicine, memorial sloan kettering cancer center, new york, ny, usa. Here is the online karnofsky performance scale calculator for you to calculate the karnofsky performance scale cancer.
Grade 1 indicates that the patient is able to do light work or activity. Eastern cooperative oncology group performance status. The karnofsky index describes the levels of activity and independence using scores from 0 to 100. To conduct clinical trials for the treatment of cancer in a consistent manner across many participating hospitals, cancer centers, and clinics requires the use of standard criteria for measuring how the disease impacts a patients daily living abilities known to physicians and researchers as a patients performance status. Functional assessment staging fast scale or fast score pdf, 90 kb online bode index calculator for copd survival prediction. Dec 22, 2017 performance status ecog karnofsky scale rr nisha shri. The level of association between functional performance status. The ecog scoring system measures how much the cancer is impacting a patients daily living abilities performance status. The eastern cooperative oncology groupworld health organization performance status ecogwho ps is a prognostic factor. Eastern cooperative oncology group ecog, gynaecologic oncology group gog and karnofsky performance status scale conversion ecog who psgog ps karnofsky ps 0 fully active, able to carry on all predisease performance without restriction 100 normal, no complaints, no evidence of disease 90 able to carry on normal activity. These scales and criteria are used by doctors and researchers to. Performance status is rarely recorded in surgery, often the place where cancer is. How do clinicians rate patients performance status using. The karnofskys index of performance status kps and the eastern cooperative oncology group performance status scale ecog ps are widely used methods of assessing the functional status of cancer patients.
The ecog performance status determines ability of patient to tolerate therapies in serious illness, specifically for chemotherapy, simpler than the karnofsky scale. Fully active, able to carry on all predisease activities with restriction ks 90100 1. Ecog seems to be a little easier considering that it is a 04 score as compared to tedious percentages expressed in some of the other assessments consultant medical oncologist. The original study was devised in 1960 as a five item scale by the eastern cooperative oncology group ecog, now part of the ecog acrin cancer research group. Simple prognostic model for patients with advanced cancer. The medical community has developed scoring systems to try to quantify or more precisely evaluate whether a patient is healthy enough for chemo. Restricted in physically strenuous activity but ambulatory and able to carry out work of a light or sedentary nature ks 7080 2. For centers that collect only the ecog performance score, see the memorandum and worksheet example here. Eastern cooperative oncology group ecog performance scale. Differences in performance status assessment among. Italy the karnofskys index of performance status kps and the eastern cooperative oncology group performance status scale ecog ps are widely used methods of assessing the functional status of cancer patients. The palliative performance scale version 2 ppsv2 tool is to victoria hospice society and replaces the first pps published in 1996 j pall care 94. Its advantage over the karnofsky scale lies in its simplicity. Eastern cooperative oncology group performance status ecog ps scale and karnofsky performance status kps scale are the two most widely used measurement instruments to evaluate the performance status of mrcc patients 28,29,30,31.
The most widely used instruments are barthel index bi for pamd and patients with multiple comorbidities, and palliative performance scale pps and eastern cooperative oncology groupperformance status ecogps for patients with cancer. Comparing physician and nurse eastern cooperative oncology. This scale ranges from 10 moribund to 100 no limitations. Differences in performance status assessment among palliative. These scales and criteria are used by doctors and researchers to assess how a patients disease is progressing, assess how the disease affects the daily living abilities of the patient, and determine appropriate treatment and prognosis. Who performance status grade explanation of activity 0 fully active, able to carry on all predisease performance without restriction 1 restricted in physically strenuous activity but ambulatory and able to carry out work of a light or sedentary nature, e. Forse loncologa e stata troppo generosa nellassegnarmi per il performance status. Aug 12, 2014 the eastern cooperative oncology group ecog scale is most commonly employed in oncology settings, although the karnofsky performance status kps 14 is also used. Programs may use ppsv2 with appropriate recognition. Performance status in patients with cancer oncology. Fitness scores are not a measure of how the cancer has advanced or how much of a threat it poses. This eastern cooperative oncology group ecog score for performance status calculator assesses the functional status of cancer patients stratified for malignancy chemotherapy. The ecog ps scale ranges from 0 healthy, no pain to 5 death table 2.
The ecog performance status is in the public domain therefore available for public use. Guideline for estimating length of survival in palliative. Some transplant centers may prefer to collect and use the ecog performance score as opposed to the karnofskylansky score. Ecog performance status radiology reference article.
These include the karnofsky score and the who ecog score. Ecog, pps, and kps were completed by physicians for each new patient attending the princess margaret can. In this study, we compare their predictive validity, and suggest a table. Karnofsky score calculator karnofsky performance status. This document has been classified as public information. Comparison of ecogwho performance status and asa score as a. Comparison of ecogwho performance status and asa score as.
According to the literature, major advantages of one method. Gordon zubrod, runs from 0 to 5, with 0 denoting perfect health and 5 death. The ecog scale of performance status is one such measurement. The instruments or scales most used are the karnofsky index and the ecog eastern cooperative oncology group or zubrod performance status. Eastern cooperative oncology group performance status ecog. Appraisal of the karnofsky performance status and proposal of a simple algorithmic system for its evaluation article pdf available in bmc medical informatics and decision making 1. Eastern cooperative oncology group ecog performance. These scales and criteria are used by doctors and researchers to assess how a patients disease is progressing, assess how the. This can be used to compare effectiveness of different therapies and to assess the prognosis in individual patients.
Toxicity and response criteria of the eastern cooperative oncology group. Review article moving beyond karnofsky and ecog performance status assessments with new technologies ciaram. How do clinicians rate patients performance status using the. It should be used in analyzing health outcomes such as riskadjusted hospital performance models in cancer populations. Flacc pain scale pdf, 92 kb flacker mortality scoring tool pdf, 86 kb karnofsky performance status scale kps pdf, 65 kb esas edmonton symptom assessment system revised pain assessment in advanced dementia. Evidencebased recommendations on carmustine implants gliadel and temozolomide temodal for newly diagnosed highgrade glioma brain tumour. Palliative performance scale % ambulation activity and evidence of disease selfcare intake conscious level 100 full normal activity no evidence of disease full normal full 90 full normal activity some evidence of disease full normal full 80 full normal activity witheffort some evidence of disease full normal or reduced full. Performance status assessment is essential in oncology, given its prognostic abilities regarding treatment tolerability and patient survival. The lower the karnofsky score, the worse the survival for most serious illnesses. Fully active, able to carry on all predisease performance without restriction. The ecog performance status and other performance scales should be used in the holistic assessment of cancer. Ecog uses a singlestatus assessment that clinicians may use to evaluate a patients disease progression, the effect of the disease on daily living abilities, and appropriate treatment and prognosis.
They are included here for health care professionals to access. The eastern cooperative oncology group ecog is one of the largest clinical cancer research organizations in the united states and conducts clinical trials in all types of adult cancers. Our data are consistent with and lend further support to this concept. It describes a patients level of functioning in terms of their ability to care for themself, daily. Although the ecog and karnofskylansky performance score systems are based on similar principles, the scales are not the same. Performance status ecog karnofsky scale rr nisha shri. Although the ecog performance status serves its purpose well in classifying patients to guide treatment selection, it has limitations in describing functionality. Karnofsky performance scale introduction the karnofsky performance scale kps is an assessment tool for predicting the length of survival in terminally ill patients. The second version of the score, the one used by this tool, was created in 1982, following a study by oken et al. The palliative performance scale pps is a modification of the karnofsky performance scale kps, designed specifically for measurement of physical status in palliative care table 2. Eastern cooperative oncology group ecog performance status determines ability of patient to tolerate therapies in serious illness, specifically for chemotherapy, simpler than the karnofsky scale. The zubrod performance status and the karnofsky index in. How do clinicians rate patients performance status using the ecog. Review article moving beyond karnofsky and ecog performance.
149 987 423 675 718 70 357 471 336 14 816 914 177 425 1248 401 316 1475 1212 776 300 405 477 1270 107 499 134 876 1488 667 1093 1082 263 1190 668 225 1319 719 1065 1352 819